on balance turkey's membership is beneficial to nato

Day by day Turkey looks less like an ally and more like Turkey participated in Baltic Sea air patrols demonstrating support for the NATO Baltic states (2006). This article outlinesmanyreasons for Turkey to remain as a NATO member. Pope Francis urged Hungarians to open their doors to others on Sunday, as he wrapped up a weekend visit with a plea for Europe to welcome migrants and the poor and for an end to Russias war in Ukraine. When Turkey goes to the polls next month, they likely will also be determining Sweden's future with NATO. Government circles point at US reluctance to supply necessary high-tech weapons to Turkey (e.g., US Congress restrictions) and to the strict control over their use and transfer of technology. Turkeys departure from NATO may be historically inevitable but it is irresponsible for Washington elites to accelerate a process that could begin the unraveling of NATO. Washingtons foreign policy elites are so fixated on recent Kurdish contributions to defeating the Islamic State (ISIS) that they seem to have forgotten Turkeys much longer record as an ally of the U.S. and NATO: Turkeys membership in NATO quelled the long cycle of conflicts and wars with Greece, also a NATO member. During the early Cold War, Turkey agreed to basing U.S. nuclear bombers and IRBMs on its territory, making Turkey a nuclear target for the USSR. second-largest standing military force in NATO, Greek and Turkish frigates nearly collided, SCOTUS Now Just Another Congressional Committee, Trump Ramps up Attacks on DeSantis: 'Dropping Like a Rock', Russian Strikes on Pavlohrad Aim to Hamper Ukraine's Counteroffensive, Greg Abbott Criticized for Response to Texas Shooting: 'A New Low', Democrat Sold First Republic Stock, Bought JP Morgan Before Collapse, Conservative Influencers Struggle With Countering Biden's Messaging. Con Turkey and Nato are no longer aligned, even if they wont admit it (2022). Cevikoz said in a parliamentary address in March that his party respects the steps Sweden has taken to address Turkish concerns. Turkey provided military and intelligence support to U.S. operations that destroyed the ISIS terrorist caliphate.. Not only did it purchase a Russian S-400 air defense system, but its gunboat diplomacy in the eastern Mediterranean also raised the specter of military conflict between NATO allies when Greek and Turkish naval flotillas steamed directly toward each other this past summer. Turkey has long benefited from its membership of NATO. How does Turkey-Azerbaijan military alliance fit into Russias demands for NATO? Turkeys actions in Syria and recent ties with Russia raise concerns over the alliances integrity. This article identifies the many ways Turkey is undermining NATOs interests and claims the conflicts between NATO and Turkey cannot be resolved. 3- Turkey wanted to show that it rewards progress and it doesnt categorically and ideologically block Nordic countries, one person with knowledge said. Seeking more autonomy in the international arena and making sovereign decisions concerning weapon purchases unite people behind Erdoan. The views expressed by contributors are their own and not the view of The Hill, by Peter Pry, opinion contributor - 10/23/19 3:00 PM ET, by Alexander J. Motyl, Opinion Contributor, by Kyle A. Jaros and Sara A. Newland, opinion contributors, Yellen says drop-dead date for debt ceiling is June 1, Hunter Biden appears in court for paternity case, Big birds are having fewer chicks as climate changes, AI chatbot outperforms human doctors in responding to patient questions, Bidens plan to address migrant surge may make it worse, Who will replace Tucker Carlson at Fox News? There is optimism in NATo circles that after the election, things may change. However, NATO can only work effectively if it maintains legitimacy and unity in its ideals and goals goals which Turkey has failed to honor. This soon became a case of more allies, more problems. Truth is, we cant do much at Incirlik. It is no secret that there are some significant problems between Turkey and leading NATO countries, particularly the United States. It helped that Turkey also gave the alliance a foothold close to the Middle East. For further information on our quality control procedures, please visit the SWP website: https://www.swp-berlin.org/en/about-swp/ quality-management-for-swp-publications/, German Institute for International and SecurityAffairs, Ludwigkirchplatz 3410719 BerlinTelephone +49 30 880 07-0Fax +49 30 880 07-100www.swp-berlin.orgswp@swp-berlin.org, Turkey between NATO and Russia: TheFailed Balance, SWP Comment 2019/C 30, 28.06.2019, 4 Seiten, would not put the peace and deterrence pro, with Russia, as membership eases the threat, Resolute Support Mission in Afghanistan and, political reasons in justifying the purchase of, they could have purchased alternatives from, weapon purchases unite people behind Erdo, https://www.swp-berlin.org/en/about-swp/ quality-management-for-swp-publications/, Digitalisierung Cyber Internet: Die Rolle des Digitalen in der internationalen Politik, Die USA und die transatlantischen Beziehungen, Foresight: Vorausschau auf mgliche berraschungen, Die Gemeinsame Auen- und Sicherheitspolitik der EU, Russlands Krieg gegen die Ukraine und seine Folgen, Centrum fr angewandte Trkeistudien (CATS). Defense Department organizations have four years to deploy seven pillars, including 45 core capabilities of zero trust. Here are some top contenders, Group identifies dozens of news sites created by AI chatbots: report, The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order, EMP Manhattan Project: Organizing For Survival Against An Electromagnetic Pulse Catastrophe, To compete with China, the US must embrace multilateral diplomacy, Federal anti-China sentiment is increasingly seeping into state laws, Want a sensible democracy? In 2020, Turkey disregarded a U.N.-enforced arms embargo around Libya and responded with hostility when confronted by French patrols. When Turkey goes to the polls next month, they likely will also be This is especially true during a time in which nationalism is on rise in Turkey. Today, Turkey is actively taking part in many NATO operations - from Afghanistan to Kosovo, from Bosnia-Herzegovina to the Horn of Africa. Unless there is a drastic change in the policies of the U.S. towards Turkey, the Turkish alliance with NATO will endure based on mutual benefits and dependencies, and NATO will continue to tolerate Erdogans personal aspirations because it is a partner that NATO cannot afford to lose. How did the United States and Turkey end up tied together in NATO, when both their values and interests seem so far apart? The views expressed in this article are the writer's own. This is why there are so many things that both need to do to reemphasize Turkeys place in the NATO. Privacy Policy. Moscow has significantly increased its military presence in a region that Russian President Vladimir Putin considers the centerpiece of Russias power projection into the Mediterranean. Following the purchase of Russian Anti-Aircraft missile systems, the United States removed Turkey from the multinational F-35 program and withdrew from its sales agreement with Turkey over fears that Russian forces would now have access to the next generation aircraft. WebNato's secretary general warns the risk of conflict is real and President Biden says that Russia will move in. The reason why all these well-known facts are cited in this column is the fact that a perception is snowballing that Turkey is an isolated member of the alliance. Turkey still contributes to the Resolute Support Mission in Afghanistan and NATOs peacekeeping operation in Kosovo. EXCLUSIVE Turkey pushed NATO allies into softening outrage over Belarus plane, diplomats say (2021). A February article in the pro-government Daily Sabah ran through a litany of issues with the alliance: Turkey, wrote the papers politics editor, Seyma Nazli Grbz, is the second-largest military in the alliance, is a key partner in Afghanistan and elsewhere, hosts NATO initiatives around its own territory, and contributed more than $100 million in 2018. Hey, European Union, pull yourself together, he said in a speech yesterday. Rather, NATO is an important asset for Turkey, even in developing its relations with Russia, as membership eases the threat of domination by Moscow. The U.S. should rethink its responsibility of perpetual European defense and stop serving allies like Turkey their cake on a platter so that they can both have it and eat it too. Turkey has also paid back the alliance as a stalwart member, honoring its obligations by contributing to missions in Kosovo and Afghanistan and hosting NATOs Land Command. (NATO image). Currently, there are also debates in Turkey about buying Russian Su35s or Su57s in case of the cancellation of F35 deliveries. The two countries have taken some steps to resolve the issue, especially after signing a memorandum of understanding with Turkey in June, and ended their arms embargo against Ankara, but remained stalled out through the end of 2022. WebTurkeys utility as a NATO member is one of many reasons the organization has been reluctant to distance itself. One of President Trumps great diplomatic challenges and whose media coverage was unforgivably scanty was posed by his NATO counterpart, Turkish President Reep Tayyip Erdoan. TURKEYS NATO MEMBERSHIP IS AN ASSET FOR BOTH TURKEY AND THE ALLIANCE (2021). Due to the wording of the NATO Treaty articles, Turkey could be suspended or expelled under the guidelines of material breach within the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, which NATO members ratified once again in 2018. Nevertheless, among these hostilities, Turkey has been left relatively unscathed by its NATO allies. "They've thumbed their nose at us, and they've thumbed their nose at their other NATO allies.". Dr Mehmet Yegin is a Visiting Fellow in the Americas Division at SWP. To view this content, you need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser. The EU is by far Turkeys largest trading partner: in 2020, 33.4% of Turkeys imports came from the EU and 41.3% of the countrys exports went to the bloc. Imagine the threat to U.S. and Israeli interests if Turkey leaves NATO and becomes another Islamist rogue state like Iran. Russian President Vladimir Putin and Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan recently met in Sochi to discuss military operations in northwestern Syria. Status Debating Waiting for the next argument from the contender. WebThis partnership should be based on mutual support, complementarity and transparency and will contribute to addressing more efficiently existing risks and threats. Sweden played an active role in the earthquake donors conference as the president of the Council of EU, and delivered a substantial aid package to Turkey, he said. Its military was thoroughly shaped by NATOs culture, standards, and technology. (Carnegie Europe), The NATO-Turkey Relationship: Envisioning Future Prospects Amidst Growing Rifts (Perry World House), Repairing the rift with Turkey (Brookings), Turkey-NATO ties are problematic, but there is one bright spot (Middle East Institute), Turkey and NATO: A Relationship Worth Saving (CSIS), US-Turkey relations will remain crisis-ridden for a long time to come (Brookings), With Turkey, the Problem Is NATO Membership, Not Armenia (Cato Institute), Arms Control and the Threat Environment (NATO and the future of arms control), A European Option Is Not a Real-World Choice (Strengthening European Deterrence and Defense), The European Union's Turkish Neighbor: Can't Live with It, and Can't Live without It (Institute for National Security Studies), Introduction (Fire and Ice: The Russian-Turkish partnership), Introduction (Turkey-Greece: From Maritime Brinkmanship to Dialogue), Turkey, NATO, And a Shifting World: What recent years, and recent weeks, have told (National Review), Turkey Aims to Play Stabilizing Role in Afghanistan after NATO Withdrawal (Institute for the Study of War). From bad to worse: Student misbehavior rises further since return of in-person Two hospitals may have violated federal law in denying woman an emergency Federal judge rules Pennsylvania school district must allow After School Satan McConnell insists hes sitting out debt talks to disbelief. Facebook privacy settlement: Who is eligible for a payment? WebOn balance, turkeys membership is beneficial to the North Atlantic treaty organization. It is the only NATO member state in the Middle East, bordering Syria and Iraq, near Lebanon and Israel, a region that has been and continues to be the crucial crossroads of empire and history since biblical times. S-400s could be an important bargaining chip to reach concessions on these three major disagreements, especially considering the strong reactions of the United States to Turkeys previous deal attempt for Chinese missiles. In terms of alliance dependence, Turkey would not put the peace and deterrence provided by NATO at risk in a volatile neighborhood. Unfortunately, Turkey under President Erdogan is abandoning secularism and democratic norms, becoming an Islamist authoritarian state, and pulling away from the U.S. and NATO. Another confrontation took place between US Vice-President Mike Pence and his Turkish counterpart, Fuat Oktay. If the Alliance believes that Erdogan will exploit NATO to achieve his own expansionist goals, then NATO should suspend or expel Turkey to ensure the integrity of the organization. Such a situation may cause an irreparable rise in anti-Western sentiment among the Turkish people. Having no access to NATOs supply of crucial weapons, Turkey may be forced to buy more Russian-produced arms. Thus, other than the termination of the need for these indispensable security benefits or the existence of a better alternative, a divergence in policy preferences among allies even a major divergence may not be a sufficient reason to end an alliance. Ironically, given the alliances Cold War roots, America joined with Russia and declined to endorse it. Sign up and get Breaking Defense news in your inbox. A more complicated scenario is a split parliament, where Kilicdaroglu is president but Erdogan retains the majority. When it comes to Turkey-NATO ties, Ankara is regarded as more of a problem than an ally these days. This article explains why Turkey cant be a leader in the region. Turkeys S-400 Purchase and Implications for Turkish Relations with NATO. But as NATO begins to reorient itself in a world where China, not Russia, is the largest military competitor, having Turkey present as a fully contributing member is more essential than ever. This article discusses many of the difficulties Turkey has posed for NATO but does conclude that NATO needs Turkey despite the difficulties. Understanding the environment is the baseline for successful naval operations. THE HILL 1625 K STREET, NW SUITE 900 WASHINGTON DC 20006 | 202-628-8500 TEL | 202-628-8503 FAX. Trump's latest attack addresses DeSantis' overseas trips to the U.K., Israel, Florida's Covid-19 record, and polling support for the 2024 Presidential race. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Want the latest defense industry news? How does Turkey-Azerbaijan military alliance fit into Russias demands for NATO? The person reiterated that Turkey principally supports Swedens membership and actions rather than words on terrorism would resolve the issue. I am looking for any info on this topic. Over the last two years, NATOs grievances with Turkey have significantly increased. Look again at the line-up: Turkey is the odd one out and the sole Nato member, ranged Turkey has along-term policy of participating in the international organizations that Greece joins in order to maintain parity. It has now enough assets, reinforced with new ships and submarines with powerful Kalibr missile systems, to overwhelm any coalition in these waters. The alliance goes back more than 60 yearsand its been decades of disappointments for both sides. Once again, as Erdoan sees it, some of his allies are siding with the terrorists. Resolved: On balance, Turkeys membership is beneficial to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. Turkey and NATO: Resolving the S-400 Spat (2020). Privacy Center Erdogan even has threatened to develop nuclear weapons, which justifies withdrawing U.S. tactical nuclear weapons from Turkey. Without elaborating, Erdogan has said Turkey will do what is necessary as a NATO member in the event of a Russian invasion. Domestic concerns related to foreign policy are also voiced by analysts close to the government. Now move on to these Congressional Research Reports: Below are resources related to the current resolution: Can tensions between Turkey and NATO be contained? Turkish contributions to and participations in NATO activities should be better promoted in the Western media. RT @ragipsoylu: 1- How Swedens NATO membership hangs in the balance in a Turkish election? oDemocracy: Turkey doesnt have fair & free electionsin fact, theres been large political purges aimed at cleansing the ranks. On this shaky ground, Turkey may not be able to maximize its interests through its relations with Russia. Russia is scheduled to deliver S-400s to Turkey in July 2019. SWP Comments are subject to internal peer review, fact-checking and copy-editing. In an interview with NATO Review in 2012 marking 60 years of Turkey being in NATO, thenTurkish Defense Minister Ismet Yilmaz said that in joining the alliance, Turkey had made its direction, and its security, the same as the Wests. He went on: This was not a decision Turkey took only in 1952. The strikes left 34 people injured, including three children, and caused widespread damage. After a Turkish Air Force fighter jet shot down a Russian Su-24 aircraft violating Turkish airspace near the SyriaTurkey border in November 2015, trust became a casualty of their bilateral relations. Political scientist Samuel Huntington warned in The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order (1996) that Turkey eventually would turn Islamist and leave NATO. As for that whole democratic-values thing, the military stepped in to run the country about every decade or so. Turkey has also NATO never hesitated to provide anti-ballistic missile systems Cookie Notice In 2019, after years of toeing the line between cozy relations with Russia and the West, Turkey appeared to put the death knell in its NATO credibility, purchasing Russian-made S-400 defense systems, booting Turkey from the F-35 joint strike fighter program. In particular, Turkey has violated the principles of the North Atlantic Treatys foreword and Article 2, in which NATO nations agree to promote stability and eliminate conflicts in international economic policies, in its interventionism in Syria, clashes with France and Greece, and its dealings with Russia. Turkeys combination of military firmness and diplomatic sobriety offers important capabilities for NATO as it struggles to deter further Russian aggression against Ukraine. Erdogan also asked the Nordic countries to drop their formal and informal arms embargo against Turkey. Even among NATO allies themselves, Turkey has fanned the flames of conflict, with Erdogan becoming more and more aggressive in the Mediterranean. Instead, it will generate a dual dependency characterized by vulnerability to Russia and an increased need for assurances from NATO. Turkey is creeping into Russias orbit and NATO is worried (2021). Separately, at the United Nations Security Council, the NATO allies France, Germany, the United Kingdom, Belgium, and Poland introduced a statement condemning Turkeys incursion into Syria. Turkey fought alongside the U.S. during the Korean War (1950-1953). Turkey could tip the balance in the Ukraine-Russia standoff (12-10-21). However, Russia may manipulate the weapon system in a manner that is counter to Turkeys intentions. Turkeys aggressive foreign policy has marred its relationship with NATO in the past two years, and its failure to abide by international laws is becoming increasingly concerning for its allies. The U.S. can learn something from this shrewd and unashamed realpolitik. On balance, Turkeys contin Instigator / Con blamonkey 1677 rating 22 debates 93.18% won Topic #4317 On balance, Turkeys continued membership is beneficial to the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. The Swedes themselves told the Turkish officials that they cannot do much until June 1, when the amendments enter into force, the person said. Last but not least, Ankara should prioritize improving its image in the West by revisiting long-suspended democratization reforms. Nonetheless, a break with NATO is unlikely, as alliance dependence is still applicable for both Turkey and other members. President Trump is right to try to accommodate Turkeys legitimate security interests on the Syrian border, while protecting the Kurds, in order to keep Turkey in NATO. Even after Turkey apologized, contentious and confrontational developments in bilateral relations continued. The NATO members moved quickly, allowing Finland to join the alliance on April 4 with Sweden left out in the cold. Whats more, Turkey has long actively used NATO as a platform to express its concerns and views about key strategic and political issues. But NATO disappointed Turkey more than once over the yearswhen the U.S. refused to side with the Turkish invasion of Cyprus, when Germany accused Turkey of killing civilians in its battle with the Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) in its own country in the 1990s, and through Americas ongoing refusal to hand over Fethullah Glen, the U.S.-based leader of a Turkish political movement that Erdoan blames for orchestrating the 2016 coup attempt. The Turkish government did little to rein in ISIS fighters transiting its territory to join the battles in Iraq and Syria; some ISIS members even passed through Turkey to carry out attacks in Europe. We need Turkeys permission to blow our nose there., On the Turkish side, too, the marriage has been one of serial disappointments and misunderstandings. Contention 1 is Continued concessions and aid to U.S. partners, for simply being allies, are why American allies like Turkey have abused and taken advantage of these leniencies and strayed away from American interests. (2022). Finland was a bit of collateral, the issues with Sweden are real.. Required fields are marked *. Details of the attacks were gathered from a variety of sources including independent monitors, humanitarian workers, and journalists who attributed many of the 218 civilian casualties recorded by Kurdish health authorities, to indiscriminate attacks perpetuated by Turkish backed militias. Ekrem mamolu, the mayor-elect in Istanbul, has emerged as a national political figure and is now regarded as a possible alternative to President Erdoan. (President Kennedy was able to avoid nuclear war with the Soviet Union and resolve the October 1962, Turkey joined the U.S. and NATO in bombing Bosnia during, Turkey joined the U.S. and NATO in bombing Serbia during. (Theres actually no clear legislative way to do thisthe NATO charter doesnt contemplate kicking out members, though members can leave on their own, as Greece did over its dispute with Turkey.) For more information, please see our Additionally, intra-party opposition within the ruling Justice and Development Party (AKP) has become more apparent with the emergence of other potential challengers such as Ali Babacan and Ahmet Davutolu. Israel, too, will be better served if Turkey remains in NATO and, thus, a moderating influence on Islamist Erdogan, who eventually may be replaced by a secular leader. This article focuses on the general geographic importance of Turkey to NATO but also highlights Turkeys role in containing Russia in the Black Sea and diffusing the conflict in Syria. In some cases Turkey is even mentioned as a kind of non-NATO country. Turkey and the United States are engaged in a high-level debate concerning the ramifications of the deal on the NATO alliance. Besides, in addition to the ethnic and religious background of Turkeys population, it has a broad geographic reach that could not be replaced byanother NATO ally. Should a conflict erupt once more, it would be between Turkish-backed Azerbaijan and Russian-backed Armenia, presenting the potential for Turkey to, once again, be at odds with the Russian military and call for NATO aid or assistance. Do not sell my information, Contested logistics, data sharing: Army, and allies, to test 120 technologies at EDGE 2023, National Guard leaders petition Biden, Harris for dedicated Space Force branch, Army orders aviation stand down in wake of fatal helo accidents, Air Force cracks open door on hypersonic ARRW, weeks after indicating it was shut, Timeline revealed: Army, Bell flying towards FLRAA program of record in 2024, L3Harris to reply to FTCs second request on Aerojet deal around June, CEO says, Saudi Arabia, Qatar see sharp jump in military spending in the Middle East: Report, Space Force to implement Santas naughty list of contractors for under-performance, S. Korea, US nuclear agreement big first step, but might not curb long-term nuclear aspirations, DoD approves next step for GPI to defend against hypersonic missiles, Finland selects 4 bidders for MVX border surveillance jet program, RAIVEN: Sensing at the edge and beyond the pixel with embedded hyperspectral imaging and artificial intelligence, Boeing hit with fresh $245 million KC-46A charge, erasing defense sectors Q1 profits, Saab predicts great possibilities in Swedens NATO entry, warns of supplier ecosystem issues, Swedens NATO membership hangs in the balance with Turkeys election, UK denies its in talks with Turkey over submarine construction, despite Erdogan comments, Ping, Ping: Bringing autonomy to map the undersea world for the Navy, Short on amphibs for Turkey, Sudan, the Marines grapple with crisis response ethos, Poland, UK close $2.4 billion PILICA+ short range air defense deal, What DoD needs to make JADC2 a reality is Live, Virtual, and Constructive, MQ-9B SeaGuardian: Ready Today for Peer Competition in the Maritime Domain. But a closer look suggests deeper waters. As a NATO member, Turkey can rely on deterrence that discourages regional adversaries from engaging in a full-scale military campaign against Turkey. Con Turkeys Response to the Russia-Ukraine Crisis. Then Erdogan, again suddenly, dropped his opposition to Finlands membership, saying that the Finns had taken required steps. Worse, the presence of S400s on Turkish soil would make NATO assistance costlier. To develop more and better undersea charts, the Navy is combining hydrography with autonomy for the first time. OMBs opposition to establishing a SNG and directive to transfer current National Guard space missions to an unestablished Space Component will create a 710 year gap in the capabilities Air National Guard Space Units provide today, the 51 Guard adjutant generals argue in a letter to President Joe Biden. Read: The Trump administration doesnt care about allies. Web1 February 2022 Turkey Neg We negate the resolution. Turkish government circles expected that given his business background President Trump would be open to negotiations concerning the following disputes inherited from the Obama administration: the YPGs role in Syria, Fethullah Glens presence inthe United States, and the violation of Iran sanctions by Turkish banker Mehmet Hakan Attila. It will not hesitate to pursue the path most closely aligned with its own interests, no matter where it lies: in the West or Russia. A senior State Department official told reporters yesterday that the Turkish attacks on northeastern Syria targeting Kurdish fighters who have been Americas best partners in defeating ISIS in the country would help no onenot even Turkey. Turkey has activated NATOs Article 4 for four times in a bid to garner alliance support and solidarity against threats posed from Syria. Ulgen warns that the new government would still need to see some sort of progress by Swedish authorities on counterrorism, possibly executive steps like investigations against terror-linked Institutes and funding. Results of recent local elections and the rerun of the Istanbul mayoral elections have turned attention to domestic politics in Turkey. Back in 1952, with the alliance just a few years old, it expanded for the first time, welcoming two new members: Greece and Turkey. If these same NATO allies are now flirting with Putin unapologetically, the U.S. should adjust the extent of its obligation to those whose interests lie opposite of American interests. Besides, confrontation with the West delivers a rallying effect for President Erdoan and provides an excuse for economic downturn in domestic politics. We wanted Turkey in NATO because of the Cold War, Steven A. Cook, a Turkey expert at the Council on Foreign Relations, told me. In other words: Erdogen may be willing to deal if he gets to tell the domestic electroate that we forced Sweden to deliver what he wanted. russian army height requirements, detention pond advantages and disadvantages,

Marine Fuel Injection Conversion 351 Windsor, Fatal Car Accident Yesterday In Georgia 2022, Shrewsbury International School Salary Scale, Radio Caroline 648 Coverage Map, Articles O

Bài viết sau đó annabelle walker garcia
Bình luận của bạn